T-Mobile G2 with Android 2.2 Review



Nowadays, it’s not normal for smartphones to be released with slide out keyboards. Thanks to iPhone and Android devices, the trend has shifted towards virtual keyboards. But there are still users who would rather have a device with a keyboard that can come in handy during messaging and typing in long emails. Amongst such Android devices with physical keyboards, one of the choices for users is the T-Mobile HTC G2.DSC01487wtmk

The G2 is a GSM Android phone manufactured by HTC for T-Mobile USA. G2 is a successor to the first ever Android phone, the T-Mobile G1, also manufactured by HTC. It is an HSPA+ phone and ships with Android 2.2 while an official Android 2.3 ( Gingerbread ) release is out in the wild. It features a slide-out physical QWERTY keyboard with a few customizable keys. Top this off with a usual capacitive touch screen which measures 3.7 inches and a speedy 800 MHz processor, the G2 has a solid all round package of specifications. Let’s take a look at the complete specifications before going into details.

  • Display: 3.7-inch (9.4 cm) flat glass touch-sensitive S-TFT screen with WVGA pixel resolution (480 × 800).
  • CPU: 800 MHz processor by Qualcomm.
  • RAM: 512MB
  • Storage: 4GB internal storage. Ships with 8GB SD Card
  • Camera: 5mp camera with autofocus. Records video at 720p resolution at 30 fps
  • Battery: 1300 mAh rechargeable lithium ion battery. Standby power of up to 430 hours and talk time power of up to 590 minutes/.
  • Connectivity: Quadband GSM 850/900/1800/1900 MHz and GPRS/EDGE, UMTS 1700 2100 MHz, and HSPA+
  • Other: Accelerometer, GPS, Proximity Sensor, Flash 10.1 support

DSC01491wtmk

DSC01489wtmk

The box contents include the handset, a 1300 mAh battery, 3.5 mm stereo headset, an 8GB microSD card, USB cable, AC Adapter and the starter guide. It’s a very small package overall and if you have owned a G1, you’ll feel right at home with the looks of the box.

DSC01469wtmk

Display and Build

The phone has a simple candy bar design with a slide-out keyboard underneath. There’s a power button on the right while the volume rocker button and USB ports are on the other side. The SD card slot is accessible only after removing the battery which might be a let down for some but not for us. How many times do people really take out the memory card with the phone running?

DSC01474wtmkDSC01473wtmk

Under the 3.7 inch display are 4 touch buttons. The touch buttons are well placed and surprisingly, we didn’t face any accidental presses during testing which is pretty common on most Android phones. Beneath the home, menu, back and search button is an optical trackpad. We didn’t find ourselves using it much perhaps because we’re not used to having one on our phones but even Google has phased it away as evident from Nexus S.DSC01466wtmk

Then there’s the physical keyboard. Honestly, it wasn’t easy typing on the physical keyboard, to begin with but slowly we got the hang of it and wondered why they’re so uncommon now. The keyboard is full QWERTY and even contains dedicated ‘@’ and ‘www./.com’ buttons. It also has a few buttons around the space bar which can be assigned custom apps or functions. The keyboard buttons are illuminated so it’s easy to type in the dark as well.

We would have liked to have a little more feedback from the buttons but for what it’s worth, the keyboard does a good job and you get used to it.

DSC01468wtmk

G2 is thicker than the iPhone 4 and Nexus S. Also heavier.

DSC01460wtmk

The 3.7-inch screen doesn’t boast of any high-density resolution or SAMOLED technology as some current phones but it’s difficult to find anything wrong with it for its specifications. The touch recognition is instant and typing using the virtual keyboard is a breeze.


You can get an idea of the brightness, contrast, and colors of the G2 display when compared to an iPhone 4 and Nexus S below. All phones were turned up to full brightness.

DSC01462wtmk

We also compared it against the iPhone 4 Retina Display just to see how evident is the difference of more pixel density:

DSC01481wtmkDSC01482wtmk

Overall, the build quality and display are good. The build quality is something we associate HTC with while the display is actually better than many that HTC has produced. HTC has produced many disappointing ones too.

Performance and OS : Android 2.2

DSC01475wtmk

T-Mobile G2 ships with Android 2.2 and while it’s no Gingerbread, it’s no slouch either. It’s very fast and since it doesn’t contain any OEM UI on top, the stock experience is speedy. It ships with the latest versions of Google’s apps that were released around Froyo which is pretty old now so you will have to update them all before using the phone. Facebook and Twitter also come preinstalled which can be a good thing for many since these are almost essential apps now.

In terms of performance, we didn’t feel the need for a task killer during our usage. Froyo and 512MB RAM did a good job of keep all our open apps running smoothly and the 800Mhz processor also kept up with the tasks. And during heavy usage ( around 30 minutes of phone calls, YouTube on Wifi for an hour, browsing for an hour on Wifi and Twitter/Facebook/FourSquare via Edge for around 30 minutes ) the phone was still up and running after 12 hours which isn’t bad at all.

We tested Foursquare and got GPS working pretty quickly which was a relief as many Android phones can act funny with location services. As for the browser, it’s a smooth performer. When pitted against Nexus S and iPhone 4, it loses a bit ( almost as fast as Nexus S though! ) but there’s nothing missing in it that you would find in any newer Android phone. As for Flash performance, it works decently depending on the content. The browser obviously performs faster with Flash disabled. Also, you save a lot of battery by not using Flash.

DSC01486wtmk

As for the camera, our review unit was missing an SD card so we weren’t able to test it out. Apparently, the camera app wouldn’t let us save any photo/video to the internal memory. Sad, we know.

Conclusion

First the good parts:

  • Stock UI, speedy performance
  • No crapware installed
  • Physical keyboard
  • Strong built design
  • 720p video

And the bad parts:

  • Physical keyboard leaves a lot to be desired. Could have been much better!
  • Bulky! Too heavy for some.
  • Android 2.3 not officially available yet.
  • HTC Desire Z overshadowed this phone

Our pick? Buy it if you want a physical keyboard on an Android 2.2 phone with the stock UI. Or if you don’t mind HTC Sense, the Desire Z is even speedier.

Technology enthusiast, Internet addict, photography fan, movie buff, music aficionado.

  • Very nice review. I have T-Mobile G1 and I was looking to upgrade it for a long time now. But I’m waiting for a decent Android smart phone to come with T-mobile. After reading your review of the G2, it seemed good enough for me. Thanks for sharing the review.