Meta Staff Say Muse AI Agent Sent Them Other People’s Data

Meta’s Muse AI agent has sent employees messages that appear to contain other people’s information, according to internal posts from Meta employees. In tests with staff from Signal and the AI Now Institute, Muse also read Signal messages on an Android phone and a Mac by using permissions it received during setup, while the same requests were blocked on an iPhone.

Meta calls the cases “isolated incidents” in response to a Reuters investigation and says many of the odd messages were hallucinations that it has already fixed. It is not clear whether the bank balances some employees received were real or invented. Apple and Google say they are considering changes that give people more control over what AI agents can access, and the Full Disk Access controls in the macOS 27.3 beta already limit new permission grants on the Mac.

Meta Muse AI agent

Muse AI Agent Read Signal Messages

Reuters worked with staff from Signal and the AI Now Institute to repeat what one Meta employee described, an unprompted Muse reminder to answer her sister’s Signal message. On an Android phone, Muse retrieved the messages through its permission to read push notifications, which it received by default during setup. On a Mac, it used macOS accessibility and screenshot tools that Apple offers to help people with disabilities operate their computers.

In both cases Muse skipped Meta’s Connector tool for linking apps and relied on those earlier permissions instead. The same requests were blocked on an iPhone.

Meta says Muse can reach other apps only through permissions people explicitly grant, and Google says people must deliberately grant Android notification access. Signal President Meredith Whittaker called the launch reckless and wants app makers to get a consistent way to mark their apps as off limits to AI agents.

Employees Reported Messages Meant for Others

Meta employees have described more than two dozen unwanted Muse actions in internal posts since mid-September, mostly in a feedback group for the team building the agent. Muse sent staff messages about a childcare request and orders they never made, and in some cases bank balances that were not theirs. One employee asked about an offer to message a seller over a coffee table pickup, and the agent replied that it had pulled in context that did not seem to be his.

Some cases cost employees money, since Muse reported purchases that never happened, gave made-up prices for items they did buy and booked a non-refundable Airbnb stay without permission. Some employees worry the agent is mixing up conversations between accounts and exposing private data. Meta’s terms of service hold users responsible for what Muse does, and Meta warns new users that the agent can make mistakes.

A member of Meta’s Superintelligence team told colleagues in early November that Muse appeared to be hallucinating messages in response to built-in prompts that push it to engage with users between sessions, and that the made-up content leans toward uncomfortable topics such as finances and safety. He said the problems involve both the AI model and the software that lets Muse take actions. Meta declined to say how many cases there have been or why they continue.

macOS 27.3 Beta Limits New Permission Grants

Apple released macOS 27.3 beta 2 to developers on November 16, and it splits the Device Control and Data Access permission into Accessibility and System and App Protection Override. You can limit an app to specific folders or apps, make it ask every time it needs access, and see a menu bar indicator when one app is controlling another.

You only see the new flow when you approve a new permission request, and every permission already granted stays in effect. A Mac where you gave the Muse Mac app access earlier keeps that access until you remove it under Privacy & Security in System Settings. Apple says it built its accessibility tools for people with disabilities and that using them for other purposes can put personal information at risk.

Muse has passed 10 million downloads since its September 8 launch. Meta says about a quarter of the people who set up an account open it each day.

Newsletter
Never miss an Apple story
One email a day, the news that matters. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
About the Author

Imran Hussain is the founder and editor of iThinkDifferent, which he launched in 2008 to cover Apple news, reviews, and how-to guides. He has spent over 15 years writing about iOS, macOS, and the wider Apple ecosystem, with a focus on hands-on guides - installing developer betas, troubleshooting, and walking through new features on his own devices. Based in Dubai, he also loves to cover photography, gaming, and the tech industry more broadly on his social media profiles.

Leave a comment