Apple Blames Epic’s Search Terms for 122,000 Withheld Documents

Apple says Epic’s search terms swept in more than 122,000 documents that are mostly unrelated to link-out fees, and it has asked a federal judge to reject Epic’s demand for all of them. Epic wants every matching document handed over by December 2, and Apple says reviewing them first would take more than 17,000 additional reviewer hours.

Epic filed the motion on November 13 and also asks for a daily fine for each day Apple misses that date. Apple opposed the motion on November 18, asking the judge to deny it, as reported by 9to5Mac. The hearing is set for November 24. The documents cover how Apple set its proposed commission of up to 15% on off-App Store purchases, and Epic says it needs them before it can respond to that proposal.

Epic Games Apple document dispute

Epic’s search terms catch too much

Apple says the files of the seven initial custodians hold 122,884 unique documents that hit Epic’s terms, and at least 95% of them matched generic words with no mention of link-out. A search that paired “fee” with country names returned 27,270 documents, and almost 70% of them contained neither “fee” nor “fees”. The wildcard “fee” term also matches words such as “feel”, “feet” and “feed”, and in one search that paired it with “appeal”, 2,745 of 5,335 documents matched only those words and just three were responsive.

Searches that paired “commission” with financial words returned 11,325 documents, and 11,050 of them were not responsive. The narrow terms did far better. The word “breakage” returned 163 documents and 105 were responsive, and Apple says five case-specific terms make up 3% of the pile but account for about 74% of the responsive documents.

Apple also says handing over unreviewed hits would expose privileged legal communications and personal data about employees, so every document still needs a review before it goes out.

Epic says Apple is stalling

Epic says Apple has produced 632 documents from the seven initial custodians, compared with about 27,000 from the same people or their predecessors in the contempt proceeding. It adds that Apple is withholding 99.14% of the documents that directly hit the terms and has not logged them, so Epic has no way to check the relevance calls. Epic also says it has received no notes of decision meetings, no internal financial analyses of the new commission and no App Store profit-and-loss statements.

More than 75% of what Apple did produce came from Phil Schiller, Alex Roman and Nate Barton, whom Apple has described as not being decision makers. Epic argues that contradicts Apple’s claim that four executives set the rates, and it says the slow production amounts to a stay of the remand that the Ninth Circuit ordered to move expeditiously.

Apple offers a Special Master sample

Apple says the December 2 deadline cannot be met. Its review vendor has already logged 20,485 hours, and producing every hit would take more than 17,000 further reviewer hours, about three weeks of work, plus seven to ten working days to build the production file. Apple says it substantially finished the seven initial custodians on November 1 and is on track to finish the remaining 20 by November 25.

If the judge wants more, Apple proposes sending a randomized, statistically significant sample of the nonresponsive documents to a Special Master by December 2. Apple also says Epic raised its demand for every hit by email only the day before filing, without the meet-and-confer the court’s rules require.

Apple adds that it has charged zero commission on linked-out purchases while the district court decides what fee it may charge.

Newsletter
Never miss an Apple story
One email a day, the news that matters. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
About the Author

Imran Hussain is the founder and editor of iThinkDifferent, which he launched in 2008 to cover Apple news, reviews, and how-to guides. He has spent over 15 years writing about iOS, macOS, and the wider Apple ecosystem, with a focus on hands-on guides - installing developer betas, troubleshooting, and walking through new features on his own devices. Based in Dubai, he also loves to cover photography, gaming, and the tech industry more broadly on his social media profiles.

Leave a comment