UK Tribunal Forces Government to Confirm Its Apple Encryption Order

A UK tribunal ruled on November 19 that the government can no longer treat its Apple encryption order as a secret in court. The Investigatory Powers Tribunal found that the Home Office had not shown that confirming the order would damage national security, in part because the order had already been widely reported, including through leaks the tribunal called authorised.

The decision means the Home Office has to acknowledge that it gave Apple a technical capability notice, the legal order that requires a company to keep a way to hand over customer data. Apple challenged the secrecy at a hearing in September, as part of its second legal challenge against the notice. The technical details of the order stay confidential.

Apple privacy and security logo

Apple Encryption Order Now Confirmed

The tribunal described the Home Office’s national security assessment as flawed in the public law sense. It pointed out that the existence of the notice could already be found online, and that leaks to The Times and the Financial Times, which it said were authorised, undercut the argument that official confirmation would cause new harm.

Home Office witnesses told the tribunal that leak inquiries had found no government source. The tribunal noted that the government produced no investigation reports, no details of the steps it took and no statements from ministers denying that they approved the briefings.

The tribunal decided only whether the government can acknowledge the notice in these proceedings, and 9to5Mac points out that the notice itself stays in place while the challenges continue. It does not decide whether the government is entitled to issue the notice at all, which is the question Apple is challenging together with Privacy International and Liberty.

Two Orders and a Withdrawn Feature

The government issued its first notice in January 2025, seeking access to encrypted iCloud backups for both US and UK users. It dropped that demand after pressure from Washington and issued a second notice that applies only to Apple’s UK customers. Apple’s earlier challenge was dismissed after that change, which is why the company filed a new one.

In February 2025, Apple stopped offering Advanced Data Protection to new UK users. The setting applies end-to-end encryption to most iCloud data, including backups and photos, so Apple itself cannot read it. Apple has said it has never built a backdoor or master key for its products, and the feature remains available in other countries.

The tribunal is not expected to hear Apple’s challenge to the notice itself until next year, and much of that hearing will be open to the public. Privacy International and Liberty are challenging the same powers in a separate case that runs alongside it.

Newsletter
Never miss an Apple story
One email a day, the news that matters. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
About the Author

Imran Hussain is the founder and editor of iThinkDifferent, which he launched in 2008 to cover Apple news, reviews, and how-to guides. He has spent over 15 years writing about iOS, macOS, and the wider Apple ecosystem, with a focus on hands-on guides - installing developer betas, troubleshooting, and walking through new features on his own devices. Based in Dubai, he also loves to cover photography, gaming, and the tech industry more broadly on his social media profiles.

Leave a comment