The federal government has agreed to a permanent court order that stops officials from pressuring Apple over the Eyes Up app. Only federal officials are bound by it, so Apple is not required to bring the app back to the App Store.
Judge Jorge Alonso entered the order on November 13 in the Northern District of Illinois. The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) sued then-Attorney General Pam Bondi and then-Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem in February for Eyes Up creator Mark Hodges, and the government agreed to make the earlier injunction permanent. The court dismissed the case with prejudice.

Eyes Up App Pressure Is Barred
Federal officials can no longer take any formal or informal step to demand that Apple suppress Eyes Up. They also cannot threaten Apple with sanctions for allowing the app or for bringing it back.
The government’s lawyers also have to tell Apple and Meta about the order. They must email written notice to both companies by November 20, including each person at Apple who was contacted about removing ICE-monitoring apps. They then have to show FIRE who received it.
Hodges said he is glad the government agreed to stop targeting his speech. He added that it should not take a lawsuit to get officials to respect constitutional rights.
Why the Judge Found Coercion
Eyes Up lets people upload, record and browse videos of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) operations on a map of the United States, and Hodges and his moderators review each video before it appears. Apple reviewed the app in August 2025 and approved it. In early October 2025 Apple removed it under its guideline against defamatory, discriminatory or mean-spirited content, after law enforcement gave the company information about the app.
In an April 17 ruling, Alonso found that Bondi and Noem likely violated the First Amendment by pressuring Apple and Facebook. He pointed to Bondi’s public statement that she demanded Apple remove ICEBlock, and to the fact that Apple reversed its approval of Eyes Up right after that contact. The injunction lets both companies make their own decisions about that speech without government pressure.
Apple has told Rep. Jamie Raskin in a letter that safety concerns Bondi raised after the Dallas ICE shooting led it to pull ICEBlock and similar apps. Raskin has asked Apple for a full list of the apps it removed and for an independent review of those decisions.
ICEBlock’s Lawsuit Is Separate
The settlement covers only Hodges and Rosado. Joshua Aaron, the developer of ICEBlock, filed his own lawsuit against Bondi, Noem and other officials in Washington in December 2025 over the same kind of pressure on Apple, and it is not part of this agreement.
(via FIRE)