The Apple trial in France is set for June 2027, after Paris prosecutors decided to pursue the company over iPhone repair restrictions. The case covers 24 iPhone models and is the first time French prosecutors have used the offense of obstructing repair and refurbishment against a company.
The French consumer group Stop Planned Obsolescence, known as HOP, filed the complaint on December 7, 2022. It announced the decision to prosecute Apple on November 17, and a hearing on February 25, 2027 will fix the trial schedule. The case matters to anyone who repairs an iPhone outside Apple’s network, since the allegation is that an unapproved repair can make the phone malfunction.
Apple trial in France targets serialization
HOP says Apple links the serial numbers of iPhone parts, such as the screen, battery and camera, to the phone through micro-chips. The phone then detects a replaced part, and HOP says it can malfunction when a repairer that Apple has not approved did the work.
The group also says it found malfunctions after repairs that used an identical, original part, as long as Apple had not approved the repair. It says these malfunctions hit the parts that fail most often for several years.
Article L441-3 of the French Consumer Code has banned these techniques since 2021, and French law treats them as an offense linked to planned obsolescence. HOP also points out that lawmakers in Europe and the United States have already moved on the issue, citing the EU right-to-repair rules.
Apple has changed its repair rules
HOP says Apple announced from 2022 that it had limited serialization on newer iPhones and now lets third parties validate some repairs. The group says these changes still need to be confirmed over time. Apple brought Self Service Repair to France and seven other European countries in December 2022, so customers there can order genuine parts and tools.
Apple has defended parts pairing on security grounds. Its hardware engineering chief, John Ternus, said in 2024 that Apple does not enable third-party Touch ID and Face ID modules because it cannot validate their security, and that third-party parts work in most other cases. Apple also said it would open repairs to used genuine parts, with an expanded Parts and Service History section in Settings that shows whether a used part is a genuine Apple component.
The trial is set for four days
HOP is asking the public to sign its manifesto, titled “Leurs pièces détachées, nos pièces à conviction”, before the trial. The group says arguments will run over several days in June.
A source close to the case told AFP that Apple Distribution International and Apple Inc will appear in the Paris criminal court for a four-day trial starting June 17, 2027. AFP reports that they are accused of obstructing repairs on a range of iPhone models from November 2021 to July 2024. If found guilty, Apple could face a fine of up to 300,000 euros or a percentage of its annual revenue, along with compensation claims from customers.