Fine M-Tec, the Korean company reported to make a metal plate inside the iPhone Duo‘s hinge, has deleted a statement in which it denied that its parts caused the foldable’s cracked screens. A company representative says Apple objected to the statement, and Apple still has not named a cause for the cracks.
Fine M-Tec posted the statement on October 26, three days after the iPhone Duo went on sale. The representative told Kim Geon of the Korean outlet The Elec that Apple objected to it, and Geon wrote about it in an editorial on the withdrawal after the representative asked him to pull his earlier article. DealSite’s report on the deleted statement has the company giving a different reason for removing it.
What the Fine M-Tec statement said
The statement denied a defect in its parts and said that tying a fault in a foldable phone to one component needs objective technical verification first.
The company also warned of possible legal action against people who blame its parts without proof, and its shares fell 15.7% that day. The statement did not name a product, but it appeared as iPhone Duo owners were posting photos of cracked inner displays.
Apple reportedly objected to it
Geon says Fine M-Tec had already withdrawn the statement when its representative contacted him. The representative said Apple objected to it, and Geon describes the objection as Apple asking why the supplier was cleared while Apple was not. He notes that the supplier is the much weaker party in the relationship, so a public statement followed by pressure over it struck him as unusual.
Fine M-Tec gave DealSite a different explanation. A company representative said it posted the statement after a tip about a short-selling scheme, meant it as a warning to short sellers and later took it down. Industry sources told DealSite that Apple manages its suppliers closely, down to their equipment and processes, so a supplier contradicting Apple in public could provoke a strong reaction.
Apple still has not named a cause
Apple said on October 26 that inner display cracking affects a small number of units. CEO John Ternus told Reuters on November 2 that only a very small share of units have come back over display problems and that Apple is replacing them.
Other theories center on the hinge itself. iFixit’s teardown found the breaks clustering near the hinge’s central support, and a leak from China blames defective material from one of Apple’s two hinge suppliers without naming it. Hyundai Motor Securities analyst Kim Jong-bae, quoted by DealSite, calls the plate Fine M-Tec makes unrelated and says the cause more likely sits in other parts or assembly yield.
Owners who see a crack can book a repair through AppleCare, and the inner display repair fee is $999 without AppleCare+ and $99 with it.